Everything in Moderation
Added on Monday, November 12th, 2007
In response to recent controversies, arguments, and heated debates in the comments section, I’ve integrated a new system in order to establish a user-moderated defense against “trolls”. According to Wikipedia, a troll is someone who intentionally posts controversial or contrary messages in an on-line community such as an on-line discussion forum or group with the intention of baiting users into an argumentative response.
Obviously people are are going to have differences of opinion, and the whole point of this site is to encourage discussion, but keep in mind that the site is called MetroRiderLA. It is written for, by, and with Los Angeles Metro riders in mind. And by “Metro riders” I mean those who ride the public transporation in Los Angeles because they like to, because they want to, and/or because they have to. Obviously anyone, including those who do not ride Metro and even those who hate Metro, can read, but keep in mind who is writing and who the target is.
It would serve no purpose for an atheist to go onto a website that promotes a religious lifestyle and post “proof” that God does not exist. It serves no purpose for a Windows user to post reasons Macs suck in a forum for Mac enthusiasts. Likewise, it serves no purpose for someone who believes that cars are the best mode of transporation to disrupt a community of people who believe exactly the opposite.
With this in mind, I’ve established a new system of rating comments in order to keep the conversation relevant and on-topic. From now on, at the end of each comment there will be a
and a
, representing a negative vote and a postive vote, respectively. If you approve of the comment, click the
or don’t click anything, but if you dissaprove of the comment and feel that it is trolling, click the
. Remember, having a different perspective on an issue is different from trolling. The
should be reserved strictly for comments that you feel are baiting arguments. For example, if someone says “cars are better” that’s irrelevant because we are Metro riders not car riders. Flag it.
After a comment gets five negative flags from unique users (you can only flag a comment once), the following icon will apear underneath the comment:
. This icon will remain with the comment and serve as a reminder that the commenter has been moderated by the other users as a troll and therefore not to engage in further conversation with the commenter.
The purpose of this system is create a fair system of moderation where the readers decide whether a comment is worthy of discussion or whether it’s just flamebait. It offers the user to opportunity to deal with a trolls comment by simply modding it down rather than dignifying it with a response (which only serves to empower the troll). Once a comment has been modded down to troll level, the icon alerts every reader of this fact - hopefully encouraging everyone to simply ignore it and move on to more constructive conversation. In the end, I hope this will reduce the uneccessary time and energy spent on arguments that can never have a conclusion and eventually silence the trolls without having to resort to more draconian measures like banning IP addresses just to keep everyone sane.



