acheter cialis 5 milligrams levitra per nachnahme viagra es de venta libre cialis necesita receta procurer du viagra viagra en pharmacie prix cialis generique achat cialis paris vente cialis 20mg efectos sildenafil mujeres remboursement cialis sildenafil en mujeres cialis montreal vendo cialis roma viagra pharmacie ordonnance farmacias viagra sin receta vente de cialis viagra ou acheter vente viagra belgique generique cialis 20mg cialis o simili vente viagra en pharmacie comprar viagra sin receta viagra luxembourg cialis 10 prix andorre cialis viagra prix au maroc acheter viagra au maroc acheter cialis en pharmacie sildenafil venta sin receta avis cialis generique viagra a vendre quebec generique sildenafil achat viagra forum viagra commander sildenafil vendo viagra france cialis comprar cialis sin receta viagra thailande tadalafil generico precio viagra ne marche pas commander viagra pfizer forum viagra pour femme cialis temoignage tadalafil pas cher viagra se vende sin receta acheter cialis en ligne tadalafil comprimidos viagra acheter acheter viagra en suisse levitra femme acheter viagra paris sildenafil magnus 50 mg cialis tous les jours kamagra oral jelly viagra france ordonnance viagra des femmes commander cialis en france cialis 5 mg 28 comprimidos precio cialis generique danger cialis inde prezzo levitra in farmacia foro viagra generica generique cialis 10mg kamagra barato cialis ou acheter acheter cialis en france comprar cialis farmacia acheter viagra cialis viagra generique en france viagra professionnel cialis 20mg achat prix viagra viagra da banco traitement impuissance commander viagra generique comprare viagra su internet kamagra thailande sildenafil venezuela effet viagra sur femme cialis a vendre viagra compresse levitra en suisse levitra inde acheter du kamagra pfizer viagra prix viagra espagne precio cialis farmacia cialis donde comprar andorre viagra kamagra gel comprar cialis online cialis en ligne viagra maroc prix achat cialis belgique cialis ne marche pas viagra prix en pharmacie viagra roma achat cialis forum prix tadalafil viagra generique pas cher commander du cialis cialis en farmacias viagra generica contrareembolso viagra acheter en ligne sildenafil comprar compra viagra generico dysfonction erectile generique viagra generique sildenafil citrate cialis donne cialis en espagne sildenafil similares levitra 10mg prix vente viagra en france acheter viagra internet venta viagra sin receta acheter cialis viagra cialis pas cher paris achat viagra andorre tadalafil para mujeres levitra 20mg generique cialis 10 mg precio viagra 100 mg viagra prix de vente sildenafil o similares cialis generique en france prix de viagra achat cialis andorre medicament cialis viagra se necesita receta medicament viagra sildenafil generico mexico cialis quotidien cialis 10mg prix cialis medicament sildenafil para la mujer acquistare viagra sicuro viagra ventajas levitra contrassegno magnus sildenafil 50 kamagra a vendre achat de levitra cialis pour les femmes viagra remboursement secu cialis generique pas cher cialis 5 mg precio farmacia cialis forum al femminile tadalafil en argentina alternativa viagra sildenafil en la mujer viagra generique sildenafil viagra receta vendo viagra antofagasta levitra 20mg prix viagra internet levitra pas cher precio cialis españa kamagra para mujeres levitra a vendre tarif cialis venta viagra contrareembolso pastilla viagra cialis en vente viagra costo in farmacia acheter cialis en suisse levitra remboursement cialis livraison rapide viagra offerte viagras en ligne cialis france cialis farmacias viagra a vendre viagra natural receta precio cialis original acheter viagra generic viagra le moins cher cialis comprar españa achat viagra belgique viagra paris cialis ordonnance precio levitra en farmacia achat cialis pas cher prix sildenafil cialis generique belgique achat viagra cialis prix cialis 20 farmaco viagra cialis requiere receta precio cialis cialis authentique foro viagra viagra en pharmacie sostituto viagra viagra natural contrareembolso levitra compresse commande cialis order viagra kamagra apcalis cialis luxembourg cialis generique prix viagra livraison rapide viagra generique forum vendo cialis milano achat viagra sur internet tadalafil dosis levitra medicament cialis sur ordonnance commande levitra viagra vrai comprar cialis sin receta comprare viagra in internet sildenafil bajo receta vente cialis france tadalafil prix cialis ca marche vente cialis pharmacie forum cialis sur internet cialis 20mg prix generico sildenafil cialis femme acheter cialis tadalafil levitra sur le net acheter viagra canada acheter cialis sans ordonnance viagra belgique sans ordonnance viagra sans prescription cialis achat france viagra generico italia viagra generico online sildenafil efectos a largo plazo achat de viagra vente viagra libre viagra pasti viagra pasteque cialis commander cialis generique pharmacie belgique viagra achat cialis original kamagra opinioni équivalent viagra sans ordonnance viagra es venta libre achat de cialis viagra generique suisse viagra sin receta tadalafil en mexico prix cialis maroc pharmacie viagra sildenafil precio mexico sildenafil mujeres viagra comprar sin receta viagra remboursé par la sécu prix viagra 100mg cialis moins cher viagra prix pharmacie levitra sans ordonnance vente viagra generique sildenafil 50 mg magnus cialis precios precio cialis 20 mg tadalafil uruguay viagra generico in italia levitra prezzo farmacia sildenafil 100 pilules kamagra inde achat viagra 20mg tarif cialis 20mg prix viagra cialis levitra originale levitra indien foro sildenafil le viagra farmaco cialis acheter kamagra gel viagra venta tarif viagra en pharmacie viagra en tunisie viagra generico forum farmacia levitra viagra le vrai levitra viagra cialis differenze sildenafil de venta libre viagras pour femme viagra a basso costo cialis meilleur prix sildenafil precio cialis prix belgique achat viagra pas cher kamagra en france forum achat viagra sildenafil comprimidos vendo viagra alicante sildenafil marcas sildenafil precio colombia venta tadalafil acheter viagra pharmacie cialis sur le net venta viagra levitra maroc viagra vente en pharmacie viagra à vendre acheter viagra sur internet commande viagra canada cialis farmaco generico viagra generique belgique viagra au quebec original cialis vente viagra france foros viagra natural impuissance erection commander du viagra kamagra contrareembolso viagra meilleur prix levitra achat acheter viagra suisse cialis achat internet kamagra 100 cialis tadalafil lilly vrai cialis moins cher viagra a andorre achat viagra quebec sildenafil necesita receta prix cialis 20mg prix viagra 100 viagra sur les femmes cialis vrai cialis vente kamagra 100 mg viagra livraison 24h levitra farmacias del ahorro acheter levitra pas chere kamagra femme acheter viagra moins cher cialis le vrai cialis 20mg belgique cialis generique achat cialis en pharmacie kamagra funziona vardenafil generique vente de cialis sur internet levitra moins cher achat cialis 20mg viagra effet sur femme comprar cialis 10 mg viagra pfizer achat viagra generique en ligne cialis europe cialis indien viagra prix belgique cialis generique acheter

We Want Our Google Transit!

Contributed by Fred Camino on April 14th, 2008 at 1:06 pm

Google Transit

Last month, Siel over at the Emerald City blog wrote about the Google Transit Earth Day Challenge first proposed by the folks over at World Changing. The idea of the challenge was to get transit agencies to get their systems onto Google Transit by Earth Day 2008, which is on April 22nd. With 8 days to go and no word from Metro, it’s unlikely that LA will be on Google Transit any time soon, but let’s look at what Google Transit could do for us.

By now everyone is aware of the ubiquitous Google Maps and its fantastically innovative way of providing driving directions, simply input a start and end location and Google calculates the best route with turn by turn directions, time estimates, and of course a corresponding map. It’s likely that Google Maps made the once neccessary Thomas Guide a bit irrelevant since its release. Unfortunately, for those without cars, the directions provided by Google Maps are for the most part useless, and transit users have had to rely on proprietary programs created by the cash-strapped transit agencies to get transit directions. These programs, like our own Metro Advanced Trip Planner, tend to be clunky, unattractive, and often teeter along the fine line of usable and unusable. And when compared to most modern web applications, especially the ones created by Google, the agencies programs just can’t compete.

The ever innovative and resourceful Google noticed this, and in December of 2005 introduced Google Transit to Portland. A year later five other U.S. cities were added. Today, 37 cities/regions worldwide have their transit systems on Google Transit, including Burbank, Thousand Oaks, and Orange County in our neck of the woods. In these cities, when anyone goes to Google Maps and does a search for directions, in addition to the normal “Drive There” option, users will see a new option, “Take Public Transit”.

Clicking the “Take Public Transit” option updates the directions to reflect various public transit trips. A list of suggested trips is offered, and clicking each trip in the menu will automatically update the map and the step-by-step directions. Directions include time estimates, distances, bus and train lines, walking directions, transfer wait times, and cost. In other words, Google Transit provides users with everything they need to know to plan their transit trip, down to the most minute details, details that are often absent from agency trip planners. And it is all housed within the same Google Maps interface we’ve all come to know and love.

Metro’s trip planner is antiquated and ugly, it’s Web 1.0 in a Web 2.0 world. Having Google Transit in Los Angeles would not only improve trip planning for current transit riders, it would introduce the transit option to non-transit riders in a way that was never before possible. The first thing most drivers do when planning a new trip is head over to Google Maps and search for directions. With the “Take Public Transit” option included with each search, drivers can see if a public transit trip would be faster/easier/cheaper than a car trip. That’s the kind of publicity that a million Miss Traffic Contests could never bring about. Google Transit does the unheard of by putting public transit on the same level as auto transportation.

Metro needs to get on this, and fast. What’s really amazing about Google Transit is that it provides its system to agencies for free. You hear that Metro, F-R-E-E. All Metro would have to do is submit its transit schedule information to Google using this handy-dandy guide that Google provides for free. Seriously Metro, have your tech guys take a break from Metro Interactive and have them get Metro on Google Transit now. Do it in 8 days and I promise I’ll stop being snarky about Miss Traffic.

Discussion

Both comments and pings are currently closed.

Please keep discussions civil: exercise Troll Controll.

There are 28 Responses to “We Want Our Google Transit!”:

  1. This would be so great, though it would take away my title as “go to” transit chick in regards to bus and train routes.

    I think the free thing is what’s bothering METRO, if only Google Transit could somehow make their service cost lots of money it would look more appealing to suits at METRO.

    METRO is kind of like a 13 year old girl, yes the payless version of the shoe looks just as good, but what if everyone finds out that you went to payless? What would happen to the social order of junior high?

    Browne

    Comment by Browne on April 14th, 2008 at 1:20 pm »Reply« resta suma

  2. I would love to see this too. I regularly plan trips between Orange County and Los Angeles, and (surprise!) OCTA is ahead of the curve on this by integrating their schedules and Metrolink IEOC / OC line schedules into Google Transit.

    Comment by Steven Chan on April 14th, 2008 at 1:55 pm »Reply« resta suma

  3. Someone should let Google Transit or OCTA know that Metrolink is not $1.25, as it states $1.25 vs. $20 driving! Haha, that sure would be nice though…

    Comment by Stephen on April 14th, 2008 at 2:12 pm »Reply« resta suma

  4. As a transit planner in Southern California who’s firm was involved in doing the leg work to help set up Google transit for several of the agencies you mentioned, i can tell you the program is fantastic. We are currently in the process of setting up google transit in several other communities throughout California and i can tell you it definitely seems to be catching on and growing quickly.

    It should be noted, however, that the process of doing the leg work for google transit is one of the most time-consuming, laborious processes known to man. We have found it takes several days to simply do the GIS (route mapping) portion of the process. Our clients already had these files made, but due to the precision required by the web-based software, every single route inevitably must be redone. For a system the size of Metro, it could take months or years to properly create all of the files necessary for Google Transit. The application has, however, been around for several years now and one could argue they had plenty of time.

    As a side note, it would also be nice to see Metro use NextBus. The Glendale Beeline uses it and it really makes using transit much easier.

    Comment by Michael E on April 14th, 2008 at 2:40 pm »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  5. I’ve seen the “Take Public Transit” link come alive only once or twice using Google Maps for Los Angeles (I’d used it before in the Bay Area) and seeing it come up, I’ll admit, was like a revelation.

    C’mon Metro, Go Google!

    Comment by Narinda on April 14th, 2008 at 2:43 pm »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  6. Thanks for the info Michael E.

    I’m sure it’s more complicated than it seems, but at the same time it’s probably easier than building a subway or implementing fare gates.

    Comment by Fred Camino on April 14th, 2008 at 3:07 pm »Reply« resta suma

  7. This is great. Many people fixed with the mindset, “I can’t get where I need to via public transit” don’t realize they can.

    My friend Paul needed to go from Burbank/Woodman to Highland/SantaMonica. He said he “needed” his car. He had no idea the 156 would take him right there.

    Of course, for those who want the glory days of the car culture to come back, finding out you don’t “need” a car as much as you think you do isn’t welcome news.

    Comment by Dan W. on April 14th, 2008 at 3:31 pm »Reply« resta suma

  8. Fred,
    Have you tried to contact Metro about their plans to interface Google Transit? What about them updating the trip planner on the Metro website?

    Comment by BlogReader on April 14th, 2008 at 3:40 pm »Reply« resta suma

  9. Michael E,
    In order to provide data to Google to use in Google Transit, would Metro have to reveal any proprietary data? If not maybe a group of software developers can work with Metro and do it on a voluntary bases. Do so see something like that being feasible?

    Comment by BlogReader on April 14th, 2008 at 3:47 pm »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  10. In theory, you could do it from your house. All you need is a cartographic mapping system (we use ArcMAP), a spreadsheet system, access to the transit service’s turn-by-turns (bus x travels east along wilshire until making a right at la brea…etc), and a great deal of patience. Chances are you will need permission from metro. It doesn’t take much in the way of computer genius (any technical support is available from Google), i wouldn’t say any of the transit planners doing this know anything more about computers than your average professional.

    To be clear, i don’t think any proprietary information is necessary, at least not with the agencies we deal with.

    I wasn’t necessarily saying the process is cost-prohibitive (especially when compared to fare gates). I think the service goes a long way toward smoothing the transition between single-occupant vehicle use and transit use. Anything helping choice riders ease into transit use is a valuable tool.

    Comment by Michael E on April 14th, 2008 at 3:54 pm »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  11. I’ve heard rumors that Metro is indeed working on this. No word on a rollout date. Anyone want to volunteer to call Marc Littman and check?

    Comment by Damien Newton on April 14th, 2008 at 6:14 pm »Reply« resta suma

  12. Michael E,

    Could you say more about which parts of generating the feed were the hardest? (Was it the optional shapes for the routes?) What problems did you encounter? What tools/languages did you need to use?

    Comment by Joe Hughes on April 14th, 2008 at 9:54 pm »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  13. Yes its true, Metro and Google are working on it. Metro Bus data is ready, Metro Rail data is being formatted. Release data hasn’t been set just yet, wouldn’t make sense to release one without the other, y’all will just COMPLAIN. And neither Metro nor Google needs more of that, at least not on this issue. (The Thai Fest article was great…)

    Also look for Metrolink to make an annoucement soon.

    As for you do-it-yourself types (developers?) test your skills using the Google Transit public feeds from participating agencies:
    http://code.google.com/p/googletransitdatafeed/wiki/PublicFeeds

    Comment by Matt on April 15th, 2008 at 7:31 am »Reply« resta suma

  14. Release data hasn’t been set just yet, wouldn’t make sense to release one without the other, y’all will just COMPLAIN.

    Oh the horror! Not more feedback from our customers! Running a transit agency would be GREAT if it weren’t for all the RIDERS!!!

    As for you do-it-yourself types (developers?) test your skills using the Google Transit public feeds from participating agencies:
    http://code.google.com/p/googletransitdatafeed/wiki/PublicFeeds

    Awesome, thanks Matt.

    Comment by Fred Camino on April 15th, 2008 at 9:19 am »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  15. Matt: Matt, please dont be kidding.

    Comment by BlogReader on April 15th, 2008 at 9:28 am »Reply« resta suma

  16. I’m not kidding. And seriously, if Metro had released bus-only data, they’d only hear how dumb they are (well, except from the BRU, they’d probably be thrilled and perhaps have a yellow-shirted press conference announcing their “victory”). The software program Metro uses to create bus and rail schedules with had a pricey upgrade last Fall. Part of that upgrade is the ability to create Google Transit friendly data exports. I’ve seen the bus test data in Google Transit and it looks great. Rail schedules, while less numerous than bus, are more complicated and are still being worked on. As an example, the geocoding of a bus stop is a single point. A subway station is a 60 story buidling on its side with multiple entry points. I know, I know, governmental BS from your point of view, you just want your Google Transit now. It’s coming!

    Comment by Matt on April 15th, 2008 at 10:19 am »Reply« resta suma

  17. It doesn’t seem like much info about what’s going on here at Metro gets out to you folks. Unfortunately, it often sounds like the worst is assumed in the absence of information. So, hopefully, the following info will help put everybody’s mind at ease.

    Metro’s goal is to make transit data more widely available – including Google Transit. We like the fact that it is free.

    1) As Matt indicated, Metro has sent and is testing bus data on a Google Transit test site.
    2) Metro will have train/subway data for Google Transit ready soon(comes from a different system).
    3) Google Maps has been integrated into NexTrip and is being tested internally for release soon.
    4) Real-time data for Metro services ONLY (so far) has been integrated into NexTrip and is being tested internally for release soon.
    5) A new Trip Planner with integrated Google Maps and a more powerful routing algorithm will be available in beta before summer.
    6) All new trip planning, routing, scheduling functions used on the web are being implemented as web services that will be available to public/private developers for integrating/extending into their own site or for creating new services. No charge or licensing involved.
    7) All of our applications are created with open source software. We do not pay license fees of any kind.
    8) Using the web services described above, a new suite of voice response applications is being developed to support Metro customers and a new 511 service for the Southland. Some of these services will be implemented this summer, others early next year.

    There are other activities on-going as well – but the above seem to relate most to your topic.

    – Doug

    Comment by Doug on April 15th, 2008 at 10:41 am »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  18. Matt = Luke Skywalker
    Doug = Obe Wwon Kenobi

    Comment by BlogReader on April 15th, 2008 at 10:49 am »Reply« resta suma

  19. Holy crap, the MTA is doing something right? Wha?!

    Comment by ubrayj02 on April 15th, 2008 at 10:49 am »Reply« resta suma

  20. Doug:

    Thanks for the information Doug. This is great news for MetroRiders.

    It doesn’t seem like much info about what’s going on here at Metro gets out to you folks. Unfortunately, it often sounds like the worst is assumed in the absence of information.

    metrorider@elhay.net

    Comment by Fred Camino on April 15th, 2008 at 10:58 am »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  21. In my humble opinion, Doug should be Metro employee of the century.

    Comment by Matt on April 15th, 2008 at 2:03 pm »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  22. That sounds really fantastic. I’m sure when it comes out, there’ll be some stupid thing we all bitch about, but it says a lot of good things that several really serious issues (bad online trip planner, lack of online friendly maps and schedules, no announcements when the next train is coming) are all on tap to be solved some time this year.

    Now if only the metro blog were actually staffed by people and those people knew this stuff and told us about it via posts…

    [See! More bitching! ;) ]

    Comment by Simon on April 15th, 2008 at 5:27 pm »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  23. Just wanted to add that we’ve been lobbying Google and the agencies in the places we live for a “Bike There” option.

    Of course, we let folks know about the Google Earth Day Challenge as well.

    http://googlemapsbikethere.org/

    Comment by Peter on April 15th, 2008 at 10:28 pm »Reply« resta suma

  24. Keep up the lobbying, Google is open to the bike project. When Metro met with Google, they did express interest in biking – We gave them the Countywide bike map as an example of the kind of info some MPO’s and multimodal transportation agencies produce. My guess is that they’re looking for the geocoding by bike lane class to be able to produce an online tool. It’s a more complex and less standardized data stream ‘cuz each responsible agency/city/county produces it own in-house non-standarized data for tracking bike lane locations/classes. Its a different situation from using the bus/rail schedules that large transit agencies produce with Giro’s Hastus system. Not impossible, and in some ways easier (no schedule on a bike lane!) but definitely a challenge for Google due to the kind of data being kept/produced (or not) nationwide about bike lanes, and which buses and rail lines allow bikes (and at what hours)…

    Comment by Matt on April 16th, 2008 at 7:27 am »Reply« resta suma

  25. Peter:

    Peter, it looks like you’re on your way to building a community of bikers on your site–why not channel some of that energy into compiling a list of bike data sets that cities around the world have put together? That way, anyone who wants to build a biking site (whether it’s Google, Ask, independent developers, whoever) will have a bunch of pointers to start from.

    Comment by Joe Hughes on April 16th, 2008 at 8:02 am »Reply« resta suma

  26. Metrolink’s gonna be on Google Transit too :) I just wrote a followup post to the one you linked to — Yay Google Transit!

    Comment by Siel on April 16th, 2008 at 10:16 am »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  27. [...] Two days ago I said, We want our Google Transit! [...]

    Comment by Going Ga-Ga for Google Transit | MetroRiderLA on April 16th, 2008 at 11:02 am »Reply« Fucking TROLL!

  28. One thing about bike data: it really shouldn’t be recommended based on the government classifications of “bike routes”, etc.

    The MTA’s own study (conducted in 2004) showed that bicycle riders in L.A. County more often use streets that are heavily trafficed by cars. That is:

    Bicyclists need access to the same destinations as drivers of automobiles. Origin and Destination Survey results show that the most common destinations for bicyclists are concentrated along major arterials, especially in areas with intense commercial activity.

    You can read more here: http://bikeoven.com/epop/

    Comment by ubrayj02 on April 16th, 2008 at 1:29 pm »Reply« resta suma